I recently bought a 2008 vibe with 144K but was getting only 25mpg. I replaced the intake manifold gasket with the orange one from toyota but was still sensing leakeage on the far right end of the manifold and now getting a p0171 error. I've now permatexed around the gasket and I think the leakage is now more local to the underside of the far right cylinder intake near where the manifold bolts to the block. I'm using carb cleaner to find leakage.
I guess I'll take the manifold off again and look for cracks.
Another symptom that came up after I replaced the gasket is my brake boost is gone and my idle is around 1000/800 which barely stays running most of the time.
Anyone have a similar experience?