#1 would be my choice too, for the wheel all by itself, but when I was shopping I found several wheels that looked great on their own, but just didn't click on the car. I also found that the diameter made a difference, e.g. when I got to an 18" or 19", I thought the open spoke designs made the Vibe look like a Conestoga Wagon and I preffered a thicker spoke. I used the "see it on your car" feature on
http://www.tirerack.com , which had over 60 wheels for the Vibe. Even if they don't offer the exact ones you want, you would likely find something close enough to help re checking the look on the Vibe.(BTW, once 'installed' on the Vibe, I liked an 18 incher much like your #3.)