In my opinion, and from personal experience on both our Vibe and my Mazda3, the Continental DWS hands down.Best set of 4 sets I've had on the Mazda since the car was new. And the Vibe, actually the first car we put them on was like night and day.If you decide on these though, be sure to add a few extra pounds. The sidewalls are a little soft and so steering response is a bit slower, but worth it in the end.
FJ's Garage Thread "There is no tool you can buy that will replace experience." - Josh Mills, C.K.DeLuxe January 2011 GenVibe MOTM
im running Goodyear Assurance Tripple Treads all year on our AWD. Seem to be really good, wear is great and even, but the only downside is they are directional so cant rotate side to side.
2006 Vibe AWD, Platinum/Graphite, Sun and Sound Package - Sisters
2007 Vibe FWD, Neptune/Graphite, Base
PAST - 04 Shadow Base, Moons and Tunes, Monotone, Traded at 23K for the 06 AWD.