OK, I wasn't sure if anyone would take much interest in a MotM 2.0 or not, and/or if there would be a discussion about how to continue the MotM process. I guess there wasn't much interest, and that's ok, but now I find it hard to sit idly by and watch while ArcsVibe becomes the default permanent Member of the Month, as much as he may deserve it, too much glory might go to his head, so for his sake, someone needs to step up and do something.So I have decided to restart MotM 1.0. I have realistic and low expectations about participation this time, so I won't be disappointed. First, two disclaimers:A. I may or may not post periodic updates thoughout the month to announce the current list of nominees, depends on how I feel, time demands, phase of the moon, etc. It will be up to whoever feels like it to advertise the MotM process, bring up proposals for rule changes, harass people for not posting in the winner threads, nag about lack of participation, drum up enthusiasm, etc., but if you think that kind of stuff is needed, then don't sit around waiting for me to do it because you'll be waiting a long time. I don't expect the actual mechanics of receiving the votes and doing the once a month winner selection and announcement thread to be a strain on my time that I can not deal with, so I decided to re-establish it. But it's up to other than me to be MotM cheerleader.B. I am just a member, not a moderator, not an admin, and I alone am responsible for content I post, and this contest is being run with only the implied consent of the site, but it is not an official thing run by genvibe management or by the wonderful company BVerticals that provides us the site in the first place. If I screw up, don't hold them accountable, and don't assume I have any more right, authority, or privilege on this site than anybody else.So, here are the existing contest rules, followed by some rule amendments/clarifications, and then the current contest status:Quote, originally posted by "GenVibe MotM Rulebook" »1. You can't change these rules2. The winner will be selected at random from those that have been nominated. If I don't like you, that will have no affect on your odds of winning. It's not about me.3. Vote early, vote often, but it won't help your candidate. Each person who gets voted for will have one entry in the random winner selection, so in the drawing, a member who has one vote gets one chance, a member who got 42 votes gets one chance. So there's no reason to vote for yourself a hundred times, that would just be sad.4. The purpose of MOTM is say "good job" to someone on the forum, and it is not a popularity contest, and it may or may not have anything to do with their car. It doesn't matter. It is about the person, perhaps someone helpful, or resourceful, or friendly, or steadfast, or whatever reason you want. The only criteria is that you have some reason to vote for a person. Whatever reason that may be, it doesn't matter. This is almost a non-rule.5. Anyone protesting the selection of the winner will be permanently prohibited from ever getting a chance to win, and will be publicly spurned in the forum. Mercilessly. Until the mods make me stop.6. There are no prizes, no cash awards, no material benefit to winning. This contest is not available where proibited by law. 7. The vote form has a spot for the members name, and a spot for why you think that person should be MOTM. If I can not trace back the name of the person you are voting for to a real genvibe username, then it gets thrown away If you don't bother to explain why you think that member should be MOTM, it gets thrown away. Really, what's the point of going to the trouble to fill out the form if you're not going to include a readable name and reason? If there is a specific post or thread that makes you appreciate a particular member, refer to it , include the link in the reason.8. Winner will be selected at random using a super secret random technique involving a high degree of randomness, which is both secret and random, and is a technique.9. The winner will be announced along with the text of the various reasons given in the ballots, or at least as much as can be reposted here and still stay within the forum content rules. 10. If you want the winner to know that you provided a specific vote/reason, then put your username in the reason, otherwise votes are anonymous.11. Genvibe members who have been banned, and genvibe members involved in the winner selection are prohibited from winning. This means me, and the bad guys. So don't bother voting for any of us. If too many people people vote for prohibited members, then I'll have to put in some sort of trap to filter those out, so spare me the trouble.12. Votes reset on the first of the month, arbitrarily at 00:00 EST/EDT13. Really, there are a lot of helpful members here, so for now I am thinking that the winning member is disqualified from winning again. ever. Might change that depending on the number of votes and the quality of all of you posting on the forum, but that's the starting rule. If a previous winner continues to get new votes after winning, I may, at my discretion, edit their victory announcement to append the new praise.14. Once the winner is announced I may, if I choose, forward non-winning nomination entries to the person who was nominated. I mean, after all, the whole purpose is to give a to someone on the forums, so if someone gets lots of praise, they ought to know about it even if they didn't win in the super secret random selection process. 15. Frivolous and/or hostile submissions will be thrown away at my discretionAmendments to these rules are as follows:Rule 1 says you can't change these rules. In order to allow the rules to be changed, I sugggest that there must first be a discussion of the proposed rule change and then a poll thread be run to get the members to vote on the proposed change. To keep from constantly changing rules, I suggest that the poll must run for at least one month, and receive a total of at least 50 votes, whichever is longer.(or does requiring 50 votes mean that the rules will never be changed? ) If the proposed rule change wins, then the new rule will go into effect for the following month. (for example, say the thread gets it's 50 votes after runing a month on November 20, the rule will affect the December MotM process). seem reasonable? let me know. Please discuss the rules and propose changes as you see fit, any criticism of the rules or the process will be interpreted as sincere interest in improving the process. Thanks in advance.Rule 8 (and 14) discuss the super secret random winner selection process. I think I already described this random process earlier in the thread, so I guess I can't call it super secret anymore Rule 12 says the votes reset at the beginning of the month. As discussed earlier in this thread, votes are now good for a three month period. For example, suppose a member is nominated today (it's October) so the nominee is entered into the November MotM contest. If the nominee does not win, that nominee will automatically be entered into the competition for the December and January MotM contest as well. Rule 14 says that I may forward non-winning nominations to the nominee. In the past I did this at the end of the month. From now on I plan to forward the nominations, if any, to the nominee as they come in throughout the month. Current Status:Picking up where I left off, the non-winning nominees from August were NascarXprt, northvibe, and zionzr2 (NascarXprt also the only one in July) so all three of these are automatically re-entered into the November 2006 MotM contest, and if they don't win, then also in the December contest, and will be joined by any additional members nominated from here on out.The MotM Ballot form is now back on line. Nominations should be submitted using the web form at
http://s93486299.onlinehome.us/cgi-bin/motm.plAnd remember, the Member of the Month contest is supposed to be a way to thank people for their contributions to the site. GenVibe is a great site, but only because of the great people that post here.