The larger rotors have a different lug pattern?! I'm scratching my head thinking I should change the hub/bearing to match the rotor. Then I'm thinking my wheels won't fit. I wound up on one of the parts sites to compare photos of the different calipers. Based on the pics I figured out that the caliper had the piston positioned further out from the mounting holes. Eureka! Not only did someone put the wrong calipers on the car before I bought it.. but to add to my confusion the parts store sold me the "2.4 version" of the rotors. What a "why me" moment

Installing the new rear calipers (100 bucks each) was much easier than I expected. I gravity bleed them for a while and finally lost patience and had someone gently push the brake an inch at a time until I was satisfied the bubbles were done. Brakes now work better than ever. If anyone wants/needs more info on this or how all this went, I'd be happy to oblige.
Everything went smoothly on the front.