Mustard: something is not right with that car in Minneapolis. Even Edmund's thinks it should be in the 9000 to 10000 range. It is a business and they should know what it is worth. Interesting enough I don't think they are member of the BBB.
http://www.edmunds.com/pontiac/vibe/200 ... value/tmv/
The one in Story City is worth a look. The pictures don't show the front and the right side. The hood is popped open. I noticed a small dent in the driver's door and maybe a smudge of sorts by the rear wheel. The price appears right for a car in good condition. Just verify it is in a good condition. You could ask them if they agree with a pre-purchase inspection. It is kind of a test question. If you want a pre-purchase inspection I suggest En-Tire Car Care near Target and Wal-Mart.
Maybe the owner has some maintenance records. If he or she can verify that they used Toyota brand fluids it would be a +. If they used generic stuff I wouldn't call it a deal killer. The car is not old and up enough in the miles to have suffered from that. But you would have to take care of it this summer.
I would use the blemishes and possibly slightly sub par maintenance as bargaining chips. I think Edmund's is estimating low and KBB is estimating high. I like a price in between the two.
Amescars on Duff Ave have a Toyota Matrix with manual transmission.
btw, I am working at Vet. Med.