Dealer did not have a new drain plug in stock so the parts guy took a used one off of a radiator he had in back and gave it to me for free - so big thanks to Toyota of Muncie parts dept.
Unfortunately it did not solve my problem. Swapped out the plugs and drove around the block a few times to get it warmed up, came home, popped the hood and looked at another puddle of coolant on the splash shield. This time I also saw a puddle forming on the passenger side, so I think that pretty much rules out a bad plug. Drove it to the dealer (took my other car last time) and service guy looks at it and notices coolant dripping from the corner of the radiator itself. So basically the radiator is shot and I'm getting a new one put in tomorrow. Not an expense I had planned for
