I think it will vary from one to the next, but my preference is the paper manuals.
The listing for the CD version doesn't really show you all that you would be getting, or if it really is the same as the printed version. Hard to put a lot of faith in the professionalism of someone who uses the term "greacy"
Still, for the price difference between the two ebay listings, if I were to buy a 2010 Vibe manual set, I'd probably first buy the CD version to see if it really is a factory manual set or if it is jsut a cheap scan of a Haynes book.. Then if it doesn't work out, forget that $280 ebay listing. You can buy the directly from the company that actually prints them at helminc.com (
http://www.helminc.com/helm/Result.asp? ... ted_media= ) for $200 instead of $280