I just bought three of your wheels from one place for my son's 06 Vibe a month ago for $150 shipped on ebay. IMO it was a steal, now I just need one more! Most of them on ebay are running about $80+ each shipped. Looks like the ones close to you on
http://www.car-part.com are running about $100 each. Brothers Auto Parts (Indianapolis) Request_Quote 1-317-352-1681 has four at $100, maybe they will give you a discount if you buy all four? At least you can actually look at them and see if they are in good condition. $300-325 a set would be reasonable if they are in good condition. Many of the places on ebay don't post pics, and I'm assuming for the reason they will show too much rash or damage.
http://www.certifit.com has unpainted mirrors pretty cheap. Don't know about the quality, but might be worth a look. Used ones on car-part range from $35-80, but then again they may be painted the right color.Oh, an if you do get some wheels and need center caps, I have several extras. The ebay ad on the three wheels I got said no center caps, so I ordered a used set of 4. Well, they DID come with them so now I have 7 center caps.