Alright, thanks for your help. I was hoping it was something a little more simple to fix, so I guess I'll just deal with it for now

Would putting a completely new radio in be the only option?

I love my vibe so much. It's a 2003 and use to belong to my dad until I got my license and needed a car to get to and from school and work. Since it's been through the years and has to deal with some overly energetic frends, the black plastic coating on the buttons is wearing off and you can see the...