Ponyota wrote: I'll be the deciding vote if I can see his car.
This is Member
of the month, not Vibe
of the Month, so the vote should go to the one you appreciate the most for what they do as a member of genvibe, and should not really have anything to do with their car. So, the existence of a garage thread or not shouldn't really matter, unless you feel that a member is more valuable if they have a garage thread, regardless of what the car in the thread is.
star_deceiver wrote:... need to figure out a tie-breaker.
You as MotM master can pick a criteria to b e a tie breaker, such as trb has averaged .22 posts per day while MrHatchWagon has averaged 1.15 posts per day, or that trb had 54 posts during April 2012 and MrHatchWagon had 41. If it were me, I'd arrange the names alphabetically, 1=MrHatchWagon, 2 = trb, and then pick some random time known only to you, and view the overall forum index, look at the total number of posts in the statistics at the bottom, and then if it is an odd number, then 1=MrHachWagon, if it is even then 2=trb. That way there's a random element, and you are only reporting the results but not deciding them.