05 base w/auto....Is it possible to improve both hp and mpg?

1.8-liter VVTL-i (2ZZ-GE) and VVT-i (1ZZ-FE) engine, transmission, exhaust, intake, and performance tuning discussions
Post Reply
wisvibe
Posts: 9
Joined: Sat May 19, 2007 8:59 pm

05 base w/auto....Is it possible to improve both hp and mpg?

Post by wisvibe »

I have an 05 base w/auto and was wondering if it was possible to improve mpg and hp with exhaust, chip or air intake. Thanks for your opinions.
ragingfish
Posts: 11022
Joined: Tue Oct 15, 2002 8:23 am

Re: 05 base w/auto....Is it possible to improve both hp and mpg? (wisvibe)

Post by ragingfish »

the two are inversely proportionate. to make extra horses, you need more fuel. certainly an exhaust or chip are not likely to do that. SOME have reported mild economy boosts from a CAI, but in most cases it drops a bit (mostly because the driver takes advantage of the additional power).
YES!I still visit GenVibe periodically. I have not forgotten about my "original" family over here!

2009 PONTIAC G8
3.6L V6 (256 HP @ 6300 rpm, 248 ft-lbs. @ 2100 rpm)
drunkenmaxx
Posts: 6300
Joined: Mon Jul 21, 2003 6:19 am

Re: 05 base w/auto....Is it possible to improve both hp and mpg? (ragingfish)

Post by drunkenmaxx »

actually fishy, exhaust can increase economy as well. anything you do to make the engine more efficient will, it just makes sense.
chew aura pizza cheat main"the world in my hands, there's noone left to hear you scream, noone's there for you"
sagekai
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 9:41 am

Post by sagekai »

By having more power, if you kept the weight of your foot the same, wouldn't the engine consistently be at lower rpm's resulting in better mileage?
2003 Vibe Base- Silver Two-Tone, Injen CAI, Sony X-Plod Head Unit, 16" Voxx MG Rims, Tein S-Tech Lowering Springs, Painted Rear Brakes, OEM Exhaust Tip, Custom Rear Seat Back Covers MiVibe-ToolGuy's Fog Lamp Protectors, 111K Miles!
drunkenmaxx
Posts: 6300
Joined: Mon Jul 21, 2003 6:19 am

Re: (sagekai)

Post by drunkenmaxx »

actually, that is a common misconception. the rpms will be the same at X miles per hour no matter what, that can only be changed by getting different gears.and that is why i laugh when people say, "since i got my CAI, i am 500 rpms lower at 55 mph" or something to that effect. lies i say!
chew aura pizza cheat main"the world in my hands, there's noone left to hear you scream, noone's there for you"
User avatar
ZubenElGenubi
Posts: 2197
Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2004 6:22 am

Re: (drunkenmaxx)

Post by ZubenElGenubi »

Yup; I admit that after I installed my CAI I thought the RPM's dropped. Nevertheless, after a couple of tanks of leadfooting it, my gas mileage did improve by a couple miles per gallon. For the sake of disclosure, I also switched from Super Unleaded to Regular Unleaded exclusively.
drunkenmaxx
Posts: 6300
Joined: Mon Jul 21, 2003 6:19 am

Re: (ZubenElGenubi)

Post by drunkenmaxx »

it does idle at lower rpms, that should make you feel better.
chew aura pizza cheat main"the world in my hands, there's noone left to hear you scream, noone's there for you"
northvibe
Posts: 7641
Joined: Tue Jul 05, 2005 2:25 pm

Post by northvibe »

after my cai my mpg went up 1 or 2, course I had to not drive hard for a couple weeks to find this out TB spacer may help too
User avatar
joatmon
Posts: 10020
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2003 5:19 am
Location: SMC MD

Post by joatmon »

The relationship between RPMs and MPH depends on the transaxle and wheels.If a mod, like CAI or exhaust increases the power output of the engine, then theoretically it would take less gas to generate the power required to move the car at the desired speed, so you might see a change in throttle position to RPM relationship.A CAI or performance exhaust will let the engine breathe easier, so you should get more power out of it for the same amount of gas. However, wouldn't the car's computer adjust fuel injection to try to keep the fuel air mix where it wants it to be, so would more air cause more fuel?Also, the best fuel economy is going to be at low throttle, RPMs under 3K. THe power band is at higher rpms. I am not sure if the factory intake/exhaust restrict air flow at engine speeds under 3K to make much of a difference. Maybe a before/after dyno chart would show if there was any appreciable power/torque gains at cruising rpms.
Image
djb383
Posts: 1571
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 1:41 am
Location: The Republic of TEXAS

Post by djb383 »

I thought we had some posts about CAI that showed dyno results indicating maybe 5 hp gain at 6500+ rpm and virtually 0 hp gain at 3500 rpm or less where we drive 99.999% of the time.
'05 Lava Tutone base, Pwr Grp, Moon & Tunes, 16" alloys, Auto.....Yep, it's gotta HEMI
sagekai
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 9:41 am

Post by sagekai »

just an observation... since i put my cai in last week, my auto is making every shift at 5 miles an hour higher than it used to... is this possibly because it requires less work on the part of the engine to go faster now... meaning better mileage?
2003 Vibe Base- Silver Two-Tone, Injen CAI, Sony X-Plod Head Unit, 16" Voxx MG Rims, Tein S-Tech Lowering Springs, Painted Rear Brakes, OEM Exhaust Tip, Custom Rear Seat Back Covers MiVibe-ToolGuy's Fog Lamp Protectors, 111K Miles!
ramenboy...
Posts: 2739
Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2005 1:50 am
Location: Chicago il

Re: (sagekai)

Post by ramenboy... »

Quote, originally posted by sagekai »just an observation... since i put my cai in last week, my auto is making every shift at 5 miles an hour higher than it used to... is this possibly because it requires less work on the part of the engine to go faster now... meaning better mileage?hmmm...5 mph higher? does that mean its shifting later? to get better gas mileage, the engine would have to shift out of the lower gears earlier. it seems that if the engine shifts at a higher speed (later), the engine is revving longer. i could be wrong
Image
de-badged o4 vibe
tein s-techs | 17" msr 105 wheels | 235 45 17 nexen n7000
weapon-r short ram (thanx BC!) | typeR sport pedals | LED 3rd brake
o2 triumph speed four
sagekai
Posts: 79
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 9:41 am

Post by sagekai »

my feeling is that its shifting later because not as many rpm's are required to reach the same speed, so by the time it gets to the rpm point to shift, the mph are higher. its still shifting at the same rpm point so basically it seems like you can get to a higher speed with less efforti could be wrong too though
2003 Vibe Base- Silver Two-Tone, Injen CAI, Sony X-Plod Head Unit, 16" Voxx MG Rims, Tein S-Tech Lowering Springs, Painted Rear Brakes, OEM Exhaust Tip, Custom Rear Seat Back Covers MiVibe-ToolGuy's Fog Lamp Protectors, 111K Miles!
ProtonXX
Posts: 193
Joined: Sun Nov 26, 2006 9:33 am

Re: (sagekai)

Post by ProtonXX »

Pulleys work great. Found 2 OBX pulleys for $120 & put them on myself. I felt more power than a CAI & Ram Air Intake & my transmission wasn't dropping a gear gears to accelerate as much.Exhaust might too but Im not ready to throw down the money for one yet. (I unscrewed my 2nd O2 sensor & pretended I have one . My mileage appeared to went up 1-2 mpg & power went up, but that could be a effect of a bad 2nd Cat.Lightweight Rims(upgrade from steelies), Syn Oil, hydrogen injection are other ideas.
Post Reply