If you are able to find a model or get the part modeled, you will want to to have it printed in ABS (and paint it) or even better ASA (and paint it). The most common 3D printing filament, PLA, breaks down quickly under direct UV (sunlight). On the other hand it might be cheaper and less work to go ...

I finally found a dealership in Texas that had one in stock. I've already tried junk yards and salvage and they are always gone. Driver's side is impossible to find, whereas the passenger side is available... makes no sense lol Thanks for the suggestions. Now I just need to replace the fog light.

EDIT* I FINALLY found the part in Texas! Being shipped to me now :) Hello! I'm new to this forum, I have only used the Jeep forums before this. I own a 2009 Vibe GT. (it is our 2nd Vibe, this one replaced our '09 base model that was totaled this summer by a deer!) Happy to be here! I love my Vibe......

HI! I am from St. Clair, near Port Huron.